The Commonplace Box Method

4×6 cards, four card types, a permanent number on every card, filing by idea, and a weekly filing hour. Built from what Luhmann, Eco, Locke and Holiday actually did, simplified so a new reader can start in ten minutes.

Card size

4×6 inches. Room for a passage and a note; the Greene/Holiday standard; close to Luhmann’s A6.

Card types

CardBorrowed fromFrontBack
Book cardLuhmann’s bibliographic slipTitle, author, edition/ISBN, dates readPage index (“p. 43 – justice as the stronger’s advantage”); at the end, Adler’s four questions
Passage cardEco’s reading and quote cardsOne passage, quoted or paraphrased; page; book code; idea heading top rightYour reaction
Thought cardEco’s idea card, Luhmann’s main cardOne idea of your own, in your own wordsCard numbers it connects to
Idea divider + index cardLocke’s headings, Luhmann’s keyword indexA tabbed divider per Great Idea; one index card at the front listing ideas and key card numbers—

Numbering

Every card carries a permanent number (№ 0412). Never renumber; cross-reference by number. Luhmann-style branching addresses (21/3a) are an optional advanced mode, not the default.

Filing

  • Book cards in their own front section.
  • Passage and thought cards behind idea dividers, filed by idea, not by book. The idea grouping is what makes the box syntopical.

The rhythm

  1. Read: pencil in the margins; jot page references on the back of the book card. No phone.
  2. Weekly filing hour: turn marks into passage cards, write at least one thought card, batch-scan, file.
  3. Closing card: on finishing a book, answer Adler’s four questions on the back of its book card:
    • What is the book about as a whole?
    • What is being said in detail, and how?
    • Is the book true, in whole or part?
    • What of it?
  4. Monthly draw: pull a few random cards and write one new thought card that connects them.
  5. Yearly map: review the blindspot map and choose next year’s reading.

Rules (printed inside the lid)

  • One idea per card.
  • A source on every card.
  • Your own words on thought cards.
  • Never throw a card away; retire it to an archive drawer.
  • The paper is the original.

Sources